Media oversimplify coverage of Aurora shooting

printer friendlyprinter friendly

In the wake of last week's shooting in Aurora, Colo., the news media have been filled with journalists, elected officials, and others bemoaning the rampage as "senseless" and "evil." On its face, this most recent rampage killing does seem senseless -- until you bring mental illness into the picture.

When people with severe, untreated mental illness are in the grip of paranoia, delusions, hallucinations and psychosis, they can be capable of doing any number of irrational and unreasonable things that are harmful to themselves or others. The likelihood that James Holmes may very well be suffering from severe mental illness, and have lost control of his rational mind, makes the shooting look less like an "evil," "diabolical" act, and a lot more like an incredibly sad tragedy born of an inadequate mental health safety net and easy access to deadly weapons.

When media coverage of these types of rampage killings focuses on the evil and depraved nature of the perpetrator, it precludes meaningful discussion about what can be done to prevent them from happening. Media coverage of Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper's comments is a case in point. Hickenlooper called James Holmes "warped," "twisted," a "creature," and portrayed the shooting as essentially inevitable: Such a "diabolical" person would have found a way to kill people even if weapons were harder to access. As BMSG discovered in past research on coverage of gun violence, this focus on the perpetrator is a common way that opponents of gun control argue against new gun policies.

In addition to minimizing the importance of gun control policies in preventing gun violence, this simplistic framing of the issue also ignores the essential role of mental health services. When people with severe mental illness are adequately treated, there is no evidence that they are any more violent than the general population. However, the mental health safety net in the United States is increasingly frayed and dysfunctional, incapable of preventing the types of tragedies that happened in Colorado.

It may make a good story to create a super-villain out of a deeply sick and disturbed young man, but villains and superheroes belong in movies, and the preventable causes of this rampage killing are all too real. We have a dismantled and crumbling mental health service system that consistently fails the mentally ill, their families, and the communities they live in. We have easy access to deadly assault weapons, vigorously defended by the companies that sell them. Add together an inadequate mental health safety net and assault rifles at every sporting goods store, and the tragedy of one family -- a son's descent into severe mental illness -- becomes the tragedy of many families.

It happened at Virginia Tech; it happened in Tuscon; it happened in Aurora; and calling it evil, saying that it is outside the bounds of human understanding, does nothing to open up a discussion of how to keep it from happening again.


mental health (2) childhood lead poisoning (1) alcohol (4) child sexual abuse (5) seat belt laws (1) built environment (2) American Beverage Association (1) obesity (9) chronic disease (2) Pine Ridge reservation (1) genital warts (1) soda warning labels (1) california (1) Twitter (1) suicide nets (1) news coverage (1) Campaign for Safe Cosmetics (1) stigma (1) tobacco control (2) food access (1) childhood obestiy conference (1) food deserts (1) Citizens United (1) El Monte (3) Happy Meals (1) media bites (1) gatorade bolt game (1) public health data (1) environmental health (1) soda tax (11) Aurora (1) elephant triggers (1) tobacco (4) cervical cancer (1) childhood trauma (2) media analysis (3) Colorado (1) soda (12) measure N (2) liana winett (1) cigarette advertising (1) structural racism (1) McDonald's (1) public health (59) suicide prevention (2) media advocacy (18) communication (2) social change (1) nanny state (2) sanitation (1) Gardasil (1) SB 1000 (1) auto safety (1) Telluride (1) obesity prevention (1) physical activity (1) news (2) regulation (2) Proposition 29 (1) digital marketing (2) product safety (1) values (1) filibuster (1) Wendy Davis (1) ACEs (2) online marketing (1) cosmetics (1) food justice (1) junk food marketing to kids (2) Measure O (1) community safety (1) sports drinks (1) messaging (3) children's health (3) Tea Party (1) world water day (1) collaboration (1) food (1) Texas (1) autism (1) social math (1) george lakoff (1) Big Tobacco (3) diabetes prevention (1) Michelle Obama (1) tobacco tax (1) youth (1) news analysis (1) abortion (1) sugar-sweetened beverages (2) sexual assault (1) Johnson & Johnson (1) target marketing (7) Twitter for advocacy (1) food marketing (3) PepsiCo (1) vaccines (1) breastfeeding (3) Berkeley (2) Oakland Unified School District (1) framing (11) sugary drinks (9) Merck (1) violence prevention (6) privilege (1) choice (1) Rachel Grana (1) cancer research (1) inequities (1) food and beverage marketing (3) Big Soda (2) FCC (1) junk food (2) summer camps (1) equity (3) San Francisco (3) reproductive justice (1) soda industry (4) Dora the Explorer (1) violence (1) front groups (1) suicide barrier (2) indoor smoking ban (1) Let's Move (1) HPV vaccine (1) government intrusion (1) sexual violence (1) snap (1) SB 402 (1) news strategy (1) emergency contraception (1) Community Coalition Against Beverage Taxes (1) paula deen (1) Food Marketing Workgroup (1) Pine Ridge Indian Reservation (2) public health policy (2) industry appeals to choice (1) Newtown (1) marketing (1) Sam Kass (1) food swamps (1) default frame (1) white house (1) new year's resolutions (1) sexual health (1) ssb (1) institutional accountability (1) cancer prevention (1) campaign finance (1) weight of the nation (1) Whiteclay (4) beauty products (1) Penn State (3) Catholic church (1) prison phone calls (1) social media (2) apha (1) media (5) sexism (1) childhood adversity (1) Sandy Hook (2) healthy eating (1) Bloomberg (3) Richmond (5) education (1) health care (1) community violence (1) childhood obesity (1) Golden Gate Bridge (2) advocacy (3) water security (1) food environment (1) gun control (2) food industry (2) Joe Paterno (1) Connecticut shooting (1) SB-5 (1) prison system (1) race (1) adverse childhood experiences (2) Bill Cosby (1) beverage industry (1) language (6) Marion Nestle (1) junk food marketing (3) community health (1) corporate social responsibility (1) diabetes (1) social justice (1) naacp (1) cap the tap (1) Nickelodeon (1) health equity (9) Oglala Sioux (3) women's health (2) gender (1) Amanda Fallin (1) tobacco industry (2) personal responsibility (3) gun violence (1) Chile (1) sandusky (2) water (1) Jerry Sandusky (3) prevention (1) SSBs (1) Coca-Cola (3) Big Food (2)
  • Follow Us On Facebook
  • Follow Us On Twitter
  • Join Us On Youtube
  • BMSG RSS Feed

get e-alerts in your inbox: